[HPFGU-Movie] Re: new uniforms? & new Dumbledore

[LeeMunLim03 at aol.com]

In a message dated 5/26/03 8:42:08 PM Eastern Daylight Time, 
illyana at mindspring.com writes:

> On Monday, May 26, 2003, at 05:10  , LeeMunLim03 at aol.com wrote:
> 
> >James Bond was totally different from harry potter. 
> 
> 
> But Batman wasn't? It seems to me that you just don't like the James 
> Bond argument because it goes against what you believe is true.


Well I am tired of fighting with you all that was a mistake I should of said 
Batman as well as James Bond

> 
> As for the Batman argument that you like to use, you may not realize 
> that there was a Batman movie made in the 60's that had basically the 
> same cast as the TV show (Adam West, Burt Ward, etc.). Although I like 
> Tim Burton's Batman films the best, he was not the first person to 
> direct a Batman movie, and many people like the 60's Batman film much 
> better than the recent four films. Therefore, Tim Burton was *not* the 
> first person to bring Batman "to life" on the big screen, and he did 
> *not* set the standard for the Batman films - he just added his 
> personal touch to the ones he made. The 60's Batman film is much 
> different than the recent ones, so someone could argue that Tim Burton 
> "ruined" the films because his two versions were so much different than 
> the original Batman film.



True but which one did you like the most ??  

> 
> As for other films that have been adapted from books, take into 
> consideration all of the films that have been made based on the 
> Sherlock Holmes books - many actors have portrayed Sherlock Holmes in 
> films and on TV, but that does not mean that any of the films or shows 
> are bad. As long as an actor portrays the character in accordance with 
> the book, there should be no problem. Of course, I am not saying that 
> Arnold Schwartzenegger would make a good Draco Malfoy, but I do not 
> think that the movie would be bad if Tom Felton decided to quit and 
> someone else took over the role. (I know that you're worried about 
> that, so I figured I'd say something about it. Hopefully, you won't 
> blame it on the director if Tom decided to leave, like you are with 
> everything else. How do you know that the actress who played the Fat 
> Lady was "fired"? Perhaps she decided not to be in POA and left on her 
> own accord - have you ever thought about that?)



Well it wouldnt be the same if Tom left the Draco role and do you really want 
a new Draco when they already have tom.  As for the Fatlady no I hadnt 
considered that.  

> 
> illyana

Kyle Longbottom 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]