"Show, don't tell" applied to PoA

alshainofthenorth alshainofthenorth at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Oct 11 22:51:27 UTC 2003


A lot of the action in PoA is second-hand before we come to the
Shrieking Shack scenes (Harry listening to Arthur and Molly arguing,
hiding beneath a table to hear the teachers talk about Sirius Black,
remembering his parents' murders when confronted with the Dementors).
I'd be curious to know what the rest of the fandom thinks the director
should do about this -- flashbacks, alternating perspectives, or what? 

I'd love to see an opening scene from Azkaban (midnight, figures in
dark cloaks, zooming in on Sirius during one of his nightmares,
hearing him mutter in his sleep "He's at Hogwarts"), but is it too
much to hope for, seeing that the latest two films have focused on
Harry's perspective? 

Another thing I'm thinking about is the Halloween Feast. Should the
Great Hall scene go on uninterrupted, or should it be interspaced with
tiny snippets like the shadow on a corridor wall, a flicker of
tattered grey robes around a corner? It might heighten the tension
rather neatly, having the audience know that a mad mass-murderer might
be inside the castle while the characters, poor innocent lambs, are
unaware... 

AHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! AHAHAHAHAA!!!!! BEWARE!!!!!
*looks around quickly*
Ahem.

Alshain





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive