[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Analysis of the flashback scene in PS/SS film

[poohnpotterfan at aol.com]

I can see that, but at the same time, she's saying "James", as she's shutting 
the door. Perhaps she's just seen what's happened to James, as she's shutting 
the door to try and save Harry and herself. I'm kind of thinking that Jo 
Rowling is possibly throwing us a red herring to kind of get us off track. But 
then again, I could be wrong!! I like everyone's theories though. They've been 
interesting to read & think about!! The one I'm always curious about though is 
in GOF, when Harry & Voldy are having their wand battle, in the first edition 
of the book, (the one I have!) James comes before Lily to help Harry. But then 
they told everyone it was a mistake & changed it in the later editions to Lily 
coming before James. I always wondered if that was a mistake or not. Maybe 
James wasn't killed before Lily? Maybe Voldy (or Snape?) made him watch while he 
killed Lily? Hmmmmmm.......loads to think about!!


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]