[HPFGU-Movie] Re: McGonnigal Played Quidditch

[Taryn Kimel]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, Kathryn Wolber 
<katydid3500 at y...> wrote:
> 
> --- werebearloony <Erthena at a...> wrote:
> > I'm probably not the first person to point this out
> > but I found it 
> > cool all the same.  While watching SS yesterday I
> > was trying to find 
> > out what year James's part said (1979) when I caught
> > a glimpse of 
> > somthing else.  Another part of the trophy said "M.
> > ?.(sorry I didn't 
> > write it down) McGonnigal"  The year undernieth
> > wasn't too readable, 
> > but the quesrtion remains, did McGonnigal play
> > quidditch? It would 
> > explain a lot, like how sheknew Harry would be a
> > good seeker, her 
> > sprightlyness, even why people pair her with Madame
> > Hooch.

Kathryn:
> Well, even if she did, the movie isn't proof enough.
> That plaque in the trophy room has the wrong position
> for James, as JKR said that he was a Chaser and not a
> Seeker.

barbienut75:
Didn't she just write in OOTP that he was a seeker, in the part 
where harry went into Snapes pensive (sp) James was playing with the 
snitch? That he had just held on to after catching? Maybe I read it 
wrong. 

Taryn:
She wrote him as playing with the Snitch, but not that he was a Seeker. He could have been playing the Snitch no matter what position--it's an small, compact way to show himself off. (He certainly couldn't carry a Quaffle around for this purpose.)

--Taryn


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]