Question about Adrain Pucey

[Phil Boswell]

I'm working on an article over at Wikipedia

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Potter_cast

and I wondered whether there had been a debate over whether the
character played by David Holmes in the second film (credited as
Slytherin Beater #1) is the same as Adrian Pucey, the character played
by him in the first film, who was however a Chaser.

If the convoluted syntax of that sentence makes sense to you, and you
can help me out, please do.
-- 
Phil