I Saw PoA!

mcmaxslb McGregorMax at ec.rr.com
Sun Jul 4 04:03:55 UTC 2004


I just saw PoA and it was fantastic!  The look of it and the acting 
was outstanding. The only thing that I thought they should have done 
was to explain about the Marauders. The fact that James's animagus 
form is the same as Harry's patronus and that it gives Harry a direct 
connection to his father which is the emotional climax of the book.  
Also as so many of you have said,it seemed that a lot of the scenes 
needed about five more minutes to them. WB needs to stop being hung 
up on running time. And where was Pigwidgeon?

  As for what was great about it, where do I start? I like that they 
made Hagrid huge. Buckbeak was amazing! And the kids are getting so 
grown up. But what I don't get is why there isn't more talk about how 
good Dan Radcliffe is. The best scenes in the movie were those 
between Dan and David Thewlis. And I don't want to start anything but 
when JKR talks about foreshadowing the upcoming books in this movie 
one of those things has to be the growing relationship between Harry 
and Hermione. 





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive