Definition of a "good movie" for me- spoilers

[Pernille]

Before I answer you I just have to say; Yes, yes and YES. I could not 
agree more with what your saying in your post. So many people have 
answered you already so I wont go through the whole list, but map 
thing I just have to comment on.

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "florenceklecka" <f.klecka at m...> 
wrote:

> Harry having absolutely no curiosity about how several people 
> know what the map is;

I didn't really bother me until the end of the film, because if I 
remember correctly, Lupin does not tell Harry about the four friends 
and the map until the end of the book. I was kind of waiting for 
Harry to ask Lupin. Then came the scene where Harry goes in to Lupins 
office at the end of the movie and talks to him alone about him 
leaving. When Lupin then is leaving and Harry stands there and looks 
at him, THAT would be the perfect moment for him to ask about it! I 
was just waiting for it to happen, but it didn't. 
There are so many completely unnecessary sequences in this movie that 
Alfonso Cuarón easily could have left out to make room for that 
moment. 

That Tom - Igor thing really bothered me too by the way.

Take Care
Pernille