[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Inconsistencies- was Definition of a "good movie" for me

[Valerie Flowe]

> From: "Pernille" <bolle17 at frisurf.no>
After seeing the movie and then reading this tread ,I get the feeling 
that the director hasn't read the book...does anyone know? And I 
thought J.K. worked on the scripts as well, at least she did with the 
two previous movies. How can she allow things like that?

Take Care 
Pernille

[from Valerie]
I've read so much so many places that I may not have my facts completely 
straight, but I seem to recall that Kloves (presumably with JKR's guidance or 
review?) had already written the screenplay for POA by the time Cuaron signed 
on. Then in an interview Cuaron said that although he'd never read HP books 
previously, he loved the screenplay so much that he went back and read all the 
books. 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]