From the main list: Rat in the Sewer

[Dicentra spectabilis]

107800

From:  "M.Clifford" <Aisbelmon at hotmail.com>
Date:  Mon Jul 26, 2004  6:34 pm
Subject:  C.O.S. Clues ; WAS Re: JKR website update

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Lady Of The Pensieve"
<chrissilein at y...> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> futhermore we learn at the updated page is, that Harry discovered in
Chamber.
>
> Any ideas about what the discovery was in CoS?
>
> Chrissi
>
> Quote:
> The link I mentioned between books two and six does not, in fact,
> relate to the 'Half-Blood Prince' (because there is no trace left of
> the HBP storyline in 'Chamber'.) Rather, it relates to a discovery
> Harry made in 'Chamber' that foreshadows something that he finds out
> in 'Prince'.
>
>

Valky:
I can't really say, yet, but perhaps we should all watch the movie
again and hunt for a possibly unecessary scene. Diverting from the
action perhaps?
I recall a greater proportion of us were fascinated with uncovering
the "almost cut" clue scene, from COS the movie, and that many of us
were leaning towards thinking that it occurred in the earlier parts
of the film.
But I wonder if now, armed with this new information, we can hold
our concentration for longer til the end of the film and extract the
answer from the Chamber scenes.

Personally am about to watch it myself.

Best to All



107804

From:  "Brenda M." <Agent_Maxine_is at hotmail.com>
Date:  Mon Jul 26, 2004  7:13 pm
Subject:  C.O.S. Clues ; WAS Re: JKR website update


>>> Valky wrote:
> I can't really say, yet, but perhaps we should all watch the movie
> again and hunt for a possibly unecessary scene. Diverting from the
> action perhaps?
> I recall a greater proportion of us were fascinated with
uncovering the "almost cut" clue scene, from COS the movie, and that
many of us were leaning towards thinking that it occurred in the
earlier parts of the film.
> But I wonder if now, armed with this new information, we can hold
> our concentration for longer til the end of the film and extract
the answer from the Chamber scenes. <<<


Bren now:

Hiya Valky!! ;P

You know, reading your post reminded me of something I found mildly
intriguing in the chamber scene in CoS movie. Remember when Harry
is running away from Basilisk, and he runs into a barred circle hole
end in the chamber? I mean, isn't it weird how that particular part
of chamber looks more like sewage when this chamber was secretly
built and no professors at Hogwarts had been able to open it? Why
is there a need for it to look like anything more than a room? In
the movie the Basilisk came out from behind the door, but this
sewage I'm refering to is far away from it. And if Basilisk has
been swimming around Hogwarts plumming, why is it blocked? I can't
recall whether this bit was in the book as well, but it is very odd,
don't you think?

So I was pondering... if there's an *entrance* to the chamber...
(are you thinking what I'm thinking...) is there an *exit* to the
chamber as well... an exit that leads to outside of Hogwarts...
perhaps to the chamber room in Malfoy Mansion...

Something to think about, no?


Brenda