PoA-In defense of Gambon, forshadowing, etc. !!small spoilers!!

[serenadust]

> --- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Tyler Hewitt" <tahewitt at y...> 
> wrote:

> > On another topic:
> > Another possible book 6-7 clue in the movie. In the scene where 
> Harry is crying under his 
> > invisibility cloak and Hermione comforts him, when Harry says 
> somethig about Sirius 
> > betraying his parents, you can see Ron in the background looking 
> kind of dejected and left 
> > out. Could this be forshadowing?


I should also have said (in my earlier post) that I thought this 
scene was a real low point in the movie for me.  I realize that it 
was meant to be a touching moment, but it was just irritating, 
mawkish and OOC for Harry to sit and weep in front of his friends.  
I can't really fault Daniel Radcilffe for not being able to bring 
this off, though, because IMO he should never have been asked to do 
something so unHarrylike (yes, it's a word.  I just created it :P)).

Jo S., who did like the movie, but has a fair few gripes