noting some more inconsistencies

alina at distantplace.net alina at distantplace.net
Sat Jun 5 22:45:06 UTC 2004


I just thought of us. It has bothered me from the beginning that 
when Wormtail transformed into a rat his clothes didn't go with him 
(but notice how they were on him when he transformed from rat to 
human). In the books, IIRC, the clothes go with the animagus. The 
main reason this bothers me, however, isn't that it contradicts that 
book, but that surely a set of extra  clothes would have been proof 
of Sirius' and the Trio's story and a contradiction to Snape's story 
(albeit, the movie decided not to show that all these people had 
stories they wanted to prove to Fudge). To me, the whole botching of 
the end of the movie is just starting to reek of incompetence on the 
part of Cuaron. 

As an extra note, I also don't like that he chose to make a 
hairless, humanoid werewolf whereas book 5 clearly tells us that 
werewolves look just like wolves with 5 minor differences. 





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive