Amandageist's review

[Chelle]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Amanda Geist" <editor at t...> wrote:
> If anyone's interested after the plethora of reviews, my impressions
after
> one seeing (must take children now, will see it again).
> 
> R
> A
> I
> N
> S
> 
> A
> 
> L
> O
> T
> 
> I
> N
> 
> S
> C
> O
> T
> L
> A
> N
> D
> 
 
> I fail to understand why it helped this movie to have things like a
> welcoming choir, at the expense (assuming time was the factor) of
critical
> plot material:

::snippy for space use::

I really likes the chior and the children randomly practicing
insturments in the background of the school for me. It always bothered
me that the only thing to do at Hogwarts after your core classes were
done was Quidditch. (Expecially those of us who watched sports in
school but never played, the music department was where it was at.) In
Book 5 theres the Gobstones Club, the Fashion Club and a few more. It
makes sense to show other things than Quidditch.
I agree with Flitwicks appearence change. It was a bit abrupt, but at
least he dosn't look like Dumbledore at the tail end of a shrinking
spell anymore :)

~ Chelle