Kloves or Cuaron??

[daughterofthedust]

Just a question for those who hated the film...
Do you blame Stephen Kloves or Alfonso Cuaron?? If both, who do you 
blame more??

Personally, I've always found his scripts to be too bloated with 
uneeded book product placement instead of focusing on his biggest 
lacking element: CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT.

In the first film, I found Snape's character lacking a sense of 
earned hatred from the trio, like in the novel.

The second, I haven't seen in a while, so I'll have to think on that 
one...

This time, I think we all agree, the Marauders plotline suffered 
(though I still think [hope] it will be in Goblet).

Ideally, as I mentioned in another post. Someone who was passionate 
for the books and equally talented as a director and writer (like P. 
J.) would take over and knock it out of the park. :-D

Of course, all fans still wouldn't be pleased, but the majority like 
those of The Lord of the Rings, would. ;-)

@)--/---
daughter