[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Kloves or Cuaron??

[Suzanne Chiles]

>>>From:   Kathryn Wolber [mailto:katydid3500 at yahoo.com]
I blame both Cuaron and   Kloves. I think
they both had some really good ideas, but that they
also had a ________certain disregard________ for the world setup but
JKR in the books and by ignoring that have allienated
the fans.   <<<

Barbara:
> You hit the nail on the head here. I wonder what the majority of the HP fans
> around the world really think. Personally, I would be really offended if I
> was JKR. I don't know how much input she was allowed to have on the movies,
> but if I put my blood, sweat and tears into a beautiful fictional
> masterpiece, I would not want some movie to be loosely based on it. I would
> want my masterpiece brought to life as close to my original work as
> possible. I really do think they had a disregard for her vision, and that in
> itself offends me.


MessageInteresting, as Ms. Rowling is on record as saying the Prisoner of Azkaban is her favorite film of the three made so far.
 
Hermione aka Suzanne