[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Kloves or Cuaron??

[Kathryn Wolber]

> In a message dated 6/6/2004 11:33:49 AM Pacific
> Daylight Time, 
> katydid3500 at yahoo.com writes:
> 
> Personally, I blame both Cuaron and Kloves. I think
> they both had some really good ideas, but that they
> also had a certain disregard for the world setup but
> JKR in the books and by ignoring that have
> allienated
> the fans.  

--- juli17 at aol.com wrote:
 Personally, I think you may be exaggerating by
> saying that PoA
> has "alienated the fans." I suspect most of fans are
> quite fine with
> the movie, and are willing to separate it from the
> book and take it
> for what it is. I am, as clearly is JK Rowling, as
> well as quite a few
> who have posted their opinions of the movie here. I
> don't begrudge 
> anyone their opinions, negative or positive, but
> let's not lump HP fans 
> together under one banner.

Ok, so maybe I shouldn't use absolutes, it has
alienated some of the fans because I know I'm not the
only person who feels this way. Better? And please do
not, and this is directed at everyone who is
disagreeing about the movie, act like those of us who
did not like the movie are just stubborn or too
unintelligent to seperate the book from the movie
because I know a number of us can and have done that
and still think the movie stinks. So please stop
treating us like we're juvenile and just wanted a
movie that was line for line from the book, because I
for one did not, I just wanted a movie that I felt did
justice to a book that I really love, which for me,
this movie did not.

~Katie



	
		
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Friends.  Fun.  Try the all-new Yahoo! Messenger.
http://messenger.yahoo.com/