[HPFGU-Movie] Re: I LIKED IT (bracing for rotton fruit thrown)

[clshannon at aol.com]

In a message dated 6/7/04 7:37:05 AM, jmmears at comcast.net writes:


> That's perfectly true.  However, since the scene where Snape assigns
> an essay on werewolves with particular emphasis on How To Identify a
> werewolf, it was a bit silly to have a werewolf that couldn't
> possibly be confused with a wolf or a dog.  Requiring that the film
> maintain it's own internal logic doesn't seem unreasonably picky to
> me.
> 

My impression of Snape's lesson was that they learn to idenify a werewolf 
when he is in his 'human' form, going by clues of his behavior or appearance. 
This would make sense then for Hermione to solve the mystery before she ever sees 
Lupin change into wolf form. I thought that Snape was talking about clues 
such as disappearing during the full moon, physical injuries indicative of one's 
roaming around as a wolf and killing prey, etc., even weakness after the full 
moon phase. Things like that.
But that's just me ;-) 
Cindy


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]