Foreshadowing of book 6 in PoA AND IMHO

[Persephone]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Diana" <dianasdolls at y...> wrote:
> As I was watching PoA the second time, I paid special attention to 
> anything that might be a possible foreshadowing of future events 
in 
> book 6.  Most are probably not important, but as we won't know 
which 
> are and which aren't until the release of book 6...so here they 
are 

While I would love to have more clues to fodder on, I must disagree 
the foreshadowing that you mention. I doubt that Ms Rowling would 
have supplied foreshadowing clues in PoA. And no one but she knows 
the ending.  

While I can not decide whether or not I like the movie 
yet ......grin......... I must say that the movie is an adaptation 
of the movie and Cuaron had creative liberties and should be seen as 
such and not a true rendition.  If anything, that will get us into 
trouble if we start seeking clues from PoA movie.  

My non-Harry Potter roomie did understand all the major points of 
the movie.  She correctly understood the Stag produced in the 
patronum, and when quizzed she understood the whole map/friend 
quadrant as well.  Her complaint was that she despises the new DD, 
she did not like the new set, her complaint too smalll; and she 
disliked the new costume.  If fact she made me watch CS and SS over 
to make me agree over the weekend.

Persephone