[HPFGU-Movie] 5 things I loved and didn't love about PoA

[Kimberly Roth]

  -----Original Message-----
  From: joj [mailto:joj at rochester.rr.com]




  5 things I didn't love about PoA.

  1.  Ron.  Not so much Rupert Grint, but (even in the books) I don't think
Ron's ever matched the level of greatness he reached during the chess match.
Things only go down hill from here for him too. (The jealousy against Harry
in GoF, and his  almost absence in OotP)  Rupert was better, but did grate
on me a few times.  (Any time he does the high squeaky voice it grates on
me) >>

  See, I liked Rupert best in this movie.  Now Ron, the character in the
book, does tick me off in GoF, but... Rupert had me in stitches during the
dream
  about the spiders. I just thought he was so adorable in this film.

  2.  Peter Petigrew.  He should have looked like a pathetic man, not a half
man/half rat.  Sirius wasn't looking or acting like a dog!
  I hope he will improve in GoF! >>

  Well, the difference between Pettigrew and Sirius is that Sirius hasn't
lived the last 12 years as a dog.  Pettigrew had to be a constant rat for
the last 12
  years.  The only thing that bothered me about Pettigrew is how he changed
back to a rat and left his clothes, when he originally transformed he had
  clothes on.  Does that make sense?

  5.  Malfoy was just too wimpy. >>

  I agree, he was too wimpy, but isn't he like that in the books too?  He's
always had a big mouth, but when it comes to taking action, he is a wimp.

   I agree with you on the 5 things you did like.  When I saw it with my
14-year old sister, I leaned over to her and said "hasn't he gotten cute",
  meaning Dan Radcliffe.  She said he was "ok", but when I told her that he
was the 2nd richest kid in Britain, she said "well, he is kind of cute."
  LOL!  Ah... teenagers!

  Kimberly






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]