[HPFGU-Movie] I LIKED IT (bracing for rotton fruit thrown)

[Tasukibeth1 at cs.com]

IAmLordCassandra at aol.com writes:

> Yes-it is clear that Lupin knew about the map and how to work it.  What 
> bothered me was that Harry never asks "How did you know this was a map and 
> how did 
> you know how to work it?".  During both map scenes I wasn't the only one in 
> the theatre who was thinking "turn around and ask, you idiot!" 

Beth says:
You know, in the final Harry/Lupin scene, where Lupin was walking away for 
the last time and Harry was watching him from the top of the stairs, I expected 
Harry to shout out to him at the last moment "How did you know it was a map?" 
and Lupin to turn around and smirk, saying "I helped write it, of course. 
Along with your father (wink)" When that didn't happen, I was actually stunned. I 
couldn't believe such a perfect opportunity was not used. Ah, such is life.

*ahem* I still liked it, though! LOL I can't change my stance now that I 
started a thread ;-P

Beth


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]