Choppy - Spolier

pitaprh 12499 at msn.com
Tue Jun 8 01:59:39 UTC 2004


I found the movie to be quite choppy.  It was as though they took the 
most important scenes from POA, filmed them and then lined them up 
and showed them.  They scenes did not flow - they would cut from one 
right to another with out them being tied together.  For example, 
when Harry cannot go to Hogsmeade he is left standing by himself in 
the garden (for lack of a better word cant think right now what that 
is called ) and the next scene is is with Lupin on the bridge - how 
did he get there?  Where did they meet up?  Add 2 minutes where Lupin 
walks up behind him and says "I hear you can't go - lets walk" then 
it would have made sense.  Many of the scenes were like that cut from 
one go to another with no explanation of how we got there.  There 
seemed to be alot of lack of explanation.  The map, the authors of 
the map, Prongs, the permission slip in the 2nd scene, Trelawney's 
prediction - Harry never meets with DD to tell him what she said.  I 
liked it, but would have liked a little more detail.  

"pitaprh"





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive