I LIKED IT (bracing for rotten fruit thrown)

[judy_magic333]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "daughterofthedust" 
<daughterofthedust at y...> wrote:

> On JKR, this is her favorite film of the three.

Judy:
Yes, I have seen here that JKR said that, and -- as I said -- I am 
baffled.  Maybe, after seeing POA, I will have an idea of where her 
head is at.  

> As for listening to the fans...Which ones?? The ones who loved it, 
> hated it, or loved parts and hated parts??...

Judy:
Why, a good cross-section of opinions, of course.  It is only fair 
for her to hear a balance of the whole range of opinions, if 
possible.  I think what fans think should matter, but that's just 
me.  And, I have *not* said that she is duty-bound to "change" her 
writing accordingly.  That is *totally* up to her, being the writer 
and owner of the franchise, and I am a big believer in individual 
freedom.  

> The rest of what you had to say sounded great (despite the fact 
that 
> I disagree) but this last part comes off as a brash generalization.

Judy:
Thank you for being so nice while disagreeing.  I hope others here 
who disagree with me will be the same way.  As for "brash 
generalization", I didn't mean what I said to come across that way.  
I hope that what I said above clarifies what I meant.  

Finally -- I see that some still are choosing to judge me because I 
have not seen POA, as if I have no right to comment until I have seen 
the movie.  Granted, my comments are based on what has been said 
here.  Am I not allowed to comment based on that?!?  *sigh*  I don't 
know when I will be seeing the movie -- it's a matter of finding the 
block of time to go -- but I will *definitely* be seeing it, and then 
make comments on what I have seen.  If some think that my comments 
are unworthy of notice until then, suit yourself.  We are all adults 
here, and have the right to decide for ourselves, after all.