[HPFGU-Movie] clues from the movie

[Dina Lerret]

At 06/09/2004 02:29 PM, Miller, Gina (JIS) wrote:

>1)    I am certain of my Snape/.Vampire theory. They left out the line where
>Lupin asks Harry about the vampire essay and I think they did that because
>with Snape closing the windows in the class and walking around at night it
>would be TOO obvious.

It was already pointed out JKR said 'no' and the shutters were closed for 
the projection.


>2)    I am with those wondering if Hermione is a werewolf, but I would come
>near thinking she is a wolf animagus.

I believe JKR referenced, if a character was to become an animagus, they'd 
take on their corporeal patronus shape (e.g. Harry = stag, Hermione = otter).

However, I did this 'outline' for an odd bit of speculation:
[[
Even if it the comparison to 'own kind' was drawn, Hermione is a female
muggleborn while Remus is a halfblood male.  Other than both having
magical blood, it still doesn't make sense.  Unless, you speculate on the
comment JKR made about the POA movie hinting at future books.  This may be
true or something done to hype up the movie for additional viewings.

If you go with the former (excuse the incorrectly structured outline -
over eight years later, I've forgotten how to do the buggers :-\ ):

   I) Hermione becomes a werewolf.
      A) Hermione is attacked by Lupin.
         1) Lupin is not forced into this situation.
            a) Unlikely based on events and consequences in POA.
            b) Some fanfic's plotline to 'ship' Remus/Hermione.
         2) Lupin is forced into this situation.
            a) Trapped and the wolfsbane potion is not administered.
            b) Hermione volunteers to become one as a defense tactic.
               i) Makes no sense because she's effective as a witch, unless
she finds herself in a situation that prevents magic.
      B) Hermione is attacked by another werewolf.
         1) Flashback to the OOTP St. Mungo's scene depicting another
'victim' of a werewolf attack.
            a) Voldemort has recruited other magical beings because of the
Ministry's lack of foresight on equality.
  II) Hermione does not become a werewolf.
      A) Hermione howling does not tie into any future books.
         1) Instead, some fanfic folk could make some pervy remarks/stories.
      B) The script adaptation has its flaws.
III) Dina has no idea what the heck she's talking about.
]]


>3)    What did Lupin tear up and throw in the fire when he was leaving?

When I was released from my last job, I ripped up and disposed of notes and 
extraneous paperwork I would no longer need.  Clean up the clutter.


>4)    I find the way Hermione was looking at Harry as he talked of living in
>the country very amusing. My SO who was with me looked at me and said, "why
>don't they kiss and get it over with?" and he does not even know what
>shipping is!

Not a Harry/Hermione 'shipper.

Dina

-- 
Mirrormere @ http://avia.silverbloom.net/mirror/
  ^-large archive for LOTR FPS or RPS, HP & Oz fanfic
LOTR RPS @ http://groups.yahoo.com/group/LOTR_RPS
My bunniqula blog @ http://archive.nu/bunniblog/