[HPFGU-Movie] Thoughts incl. Damage, Boggart, Time, Creatures,Prongs perspective, and Latin

[Ms. Found in a Bottle]

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "carin_in_oh" <aldhelm at earthlink.net>

>Thought: In Lupin's Boggart lesson, I really liked the bit where
>Lupin wasn't looking and suddenly turned around to find Harry
>at the front of the line.  But didn't it deflate things a bit that the
>Boggart!Dementor was already up and hovering in front of
>everyone in the class before Lupin noticed? It rather undoes his
>contention that he was afraid the class would see Voldemort.

My sister and I thought the same thing when we first saw the movie,
and it just did not make sense to us.  But the 2nd time we saw the
movie I thought Lupin told Harry (I don't remember the exact quote)
that he didn't realize it was going to turn into a dementor, but that he
thought that it would be Voldemort.  So, he saw that it was a dementor
after he had already stepped in front of Harry, but when he first saw
Harry at the front of the line he thought that Voldemort was going to be
there.  That's what I got from it anyway.  The first time I saw the movie we
got stuck sitting in the 3rd row, so the sound was terrible and I missed
a lot of stuff that was said, but then I sat in the back for the 2nd viewing
and a lot of lines were a lot clearer to me.

Beth