[HPFGU-Movie] I think I understand...

[Barbara D. Poland-Waters]

>>>From: Valerie Flowe [mailto:valerie.flowe at verizon.net]

I disagree there. It bothers me that Cuaron changed the focus from main plot
to sub plot. The "coming of age" was such a minor part of the book. In fact,
it is more apparent in GOF, than in POA, what with Harry + Cho, Ron +
Hermione, the dance, etc.

Because of the popularity of the HP series, a director should not be allowed
to take such liberal interpretations (IMO).

<snip>

I think the charm for many HP fans is seeing the books come to life; not
take on a new life. Masses of people ADORE JKR's stories; they don't want to
see Cuaron's story with shrunken heads and such. I just don't think one can
be separated from the other.<<<


Thanks Valerie, you have expressed exactly what I have been trying to
regarding my disliking of the movie (although I respect that you ultimately
liked the movie). You mentioned just a few of my complaints, and your
comments seem to be based on your preferences, rather than anything have to
do with canon, or some evaluation of the movie as a stand alone entity with
certain cinematic merits. That's what I have based my comments on, my
preferences. IMO that is just as valid a stance as any.


Barbara
bd-bear