Some thoughts about the next movie
amdorn
abbid at carterassoc.com
Sun Jun 20 21:13:42 UTC 2004
> vegittonomiko at y... writes:
> >
> > >>Just a thought if I may. Now, in PoA, Ron and Hermione are
> starting
> > to notice each other. What happens with GoF comes out? Will Ron
> do
> > or say something stupid to make Hermione momentarily forget about
> her
> > feelings towards him and go to the Yule Ball with Viktor Krum?<<
>
> Rebecca wrote:
> > They're not starting to notice each other quite that heavily
> though. The
> > "noticing" is mostly subtle, the same way it is in GoF. They
> weren't gazing into
> > each other's eyes or anything. Personally, I think it strengthens
> the Yule Ball
> > plot, because then Ron's jealousy doesn't come out of left field.
> The reason
> > (essentially) in the book that Hermione doesn't go with Ron is
> that he waited
> > till the last moment to ask her. I can't see any reason why that
> wouldn't
> > still work in the GoF movie.
Just a note:
In the movie all of the "tension" scenes are extra, as in Harry is
not directly there. For instance, the scene near the Shreiking shack
is "before" Harry gets there under the cloak. In addition, the scene
with the hand grab is behind Harry's back. All of these scenes are
not in Harry's line of vision. It is a possiblility that they
happened but we are not privy to this information because Harry
doesn't see it. As far as we know in canon, Ron and Hermione might
have had more "tense" moments during their first trip to Hogsmeade,
we just don't get to see it. I don't necessarily think that Hermione
doesn't go with Ron is because he waited. We just know that he did
wait and Krum beat him to the punch. We don't even know how early in
the year Krum asked Hermione. Could be right after the first task.
It could have been incredibly early in the school year. The fact is
that Ron waited and Hermione had already been asked so we don't get
to know if she would have said yes. JKR wrote it like that. I must
admit it is a nice way to keep us on our toes.
I will tell you I have a gut feeling as to who is going to end up
with whom, but this is not the list for that. Now in the next movie
hopefully we will get more of the "out-of-Harry's view" scenes of
Hermione and Ron.
Amdorn
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive