Minerva McGonagall & The SS Movie Possible Clue? NOT a Coincidence

Dacia Sycamore Dacia_S at msn.com
Sat Mar 13 17:52:58 UTC 2004


--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "snapesmate" <snapesmate at h...> 
wrote:
> brought over from the HPFGU because it talks about the movie.  I 
> thought it too good a point to be lost due to the fact that it 
> pertains to the movie aside from comparing movie vs, book...
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Frank" <fever264 at A...> wrote:
> >     Hi everyone!
 
   Minerva McGonagall doesnt seem to get much credit as being a real 
> > key to the whole septology, I feel that she is viewed as a "B 
LIST" 
> > Character.

Dacia:
I wonder why Peves was left out of the movies. I started reading the 
books after second movie came out on dvd and I couldn't beleive he 
was left out. I see him as having a more and more important role in 
the books. I would have thought Peves would have at least been 
mentioned.

Frank:
> the NAMES displayed on the GRYFFINDOR QUIDDITCH TROPHY where the 
names are written, Including "JAMES POTTER" as "Seeker", with the 
>>Year marked 1970, 
> > "M.G. McGonagall" 1971 on the name plate to the right of James 
> > Potter. ( To the left of James is "R.J.H. KING 1969" ) 
> > Now, I only brought this up b/c of JK's role on the content of 
the 
> > movies, I think this might of been purposely done. But I could be 
> > very wrong.
> > 
> > Frank (Fever264 at A...)

Lynette: 
> Good catch, I never noticed it before...  nor did I notice that if 
> you look at the plaque to the right you can see the last three 
> letters of a name, "DLE" then the Hogwarts emblem and then the 
> words "for special services to Hogawarts School"!  Gee, I wonder 
what 
> student, whose name ends in "DLE" received this award for maybe 
> catching a "giant of a man" (or halfway at the least,LOL!) type 
> student who got expelled for allegedly releasing a monster from a 
> chamber?
> 
> Lynnette, who thinks Snape IS a good guy, even if he is NOT a nice 
> guy!

Dacia:
I saw the plaque but I couldn't see any part of the name, just the 
four house crests. That was a good catch!! It took me a while to 
finally see the name on that crest as being McGonagall! I always 
wondered who King was because like you said, Rowling does have input 
and I'm sure she has the names of the players, even if they aren't 
important to the story.

Dacia, waiting impatiently for the next movie.






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive