Lupin and Sirus... gay?

[Scully931]

Yes, I saw the same thing as you did. I thought, "Oh, poor Lupin was 
in love with Lily and he's a werewolf!" Never crossed my mind about 
him being gay until I read it here either. Still don't think that. 
But, I'm not getting into all that again! :-)

Deborah

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, Valerie Flowe 
<valerie.flowe at v...> wrote:
> From: "sopraniste" <sopraniste at y...>
> <snip>
> My main objection is the scene between Harry and Lupin on the 
bridge,
> when everybody's in Hogsmeade, and they get talking about Lily and
> James. He says some nice things about James, of course, the guy was
> one of his best friends after all, but this scene made it VERY 
clear
> to me that poor Remus was in love with Lily! I thought this was a 
very
> nice addition, and it made me like poor Remus (who was already my
> favorite character) all the more. It never occurred to me until it
> came up on the list that others might see him as gay.
> 
> Flop
> 
> [from Valerie]
> I keep wondering if this is not one of the things JKR was alluding 
to when
> she said Cuaron was foreshadowing some future plot in books 6-7. 
Though I
> know in response to an interview question she said she was not 
going to do a
> "spin-off" book, expanding on the Marauder's time period. Too 
bad...I find
> it all very fascinating.
> Guess I could spend lots of time debating on what exactly will be 
revealed,
> but hey, that's another chat group altogether, isn't it?!
> 
> 
> 
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]