[HPFGU-Movie]who's that boy?

[Michelle Crowe]

I looked at IMDB for PoA and the only character I couldn't positively 
identify was "Slytherin boy", who does not have a photo available. So I 
don't know who it was, the kid in the snow or the black boy who was in 
Gryffindor colors....

Michelle

artsylynda at aol.com wrote:

>
>
> In a message dated 5/30/2005 10:41:25 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, 
> HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com writes:
>
> In PoA,  when Malfoy is hoping to watch Buckbeak's execution, there's a
> different  boy with him. (I can't keep Crabbe and Goyle straight, so I
> don't know  which one is missing) Does anyone know why? It's the same
> non-bookend boy  at the Shrieking Shack snowball  ambush....
>
> Puzzled,
> Michelle
>
>
> I believe he's supposed to be "Nott," another Slytherin in Malfoy's  gang
> (and his dad's a Death Eater).  I don't know why they didn't have  
> Goyle there
> (he was the one who was missing) in some scenes.  And that  scene in 
> the snow --
> logistically, Harry would have had to be running in circles  around 
> Nott to
> hold his scarf and spin him the way he was -- they had the  "circle" 
> wrong --
> if Harry stayed in the center of the circle and spun Nott  around, 
> Nott would
> be racing in a huge circle, not leaning back while the ends  of his 
> scar spin
> around HIM.  heehee.  Yet another PoA  mistake!
>
> For a "who's that boy" that nobody has been able to solve (to  the 
> best of my
> recollection), who's that heavy black boy in Gryffindor?   And if they 
> wanted
> those lines said by a black boy, why not give them to poor  Dean, who had
> nearly no screen time?!  I hope that heavy black boy isn't in  GoF -- 
> I found him
> quite annoying, especially since he's not supposed to be  there in the 
> first
> place!  At least Nott is mentioned in canon!!   argh. . . 
>
> Lynda