[HPFGU-Movie] movie opinions

Ms. Found in a Bottle bethz1 at rcn.com
Sat Nov 19 01:53:15 UTC 2005


I went to the midnight show with my sister and one of our friends.  When 
it came to what they decided to leave out and what they kept in, my 
first reaction when the movie ended was that I was least disappointed 
with this movie .  I thought it flowed well, and was afraid that it was 
going to be just 'task - task - task', but was glad that there was 
more.  The only thing I was slightly disappointed with was Harry and the 
dragon leaving the stadium during the 1st task, but I found the 3rd task 
and the grave yard scenes thrilling; I knew how it ended and I was still 
on the edge of my seat.

Of course, I just realized that I'm not sure if I'm qualified to answer 
this post.  I did like POA (saw it in the theatre more times than the 
first two films), but I was disappointed with it.  POA is my favorite of 
the books, so I had very high hopes for that movie, but then decided to 
just enjoy it as a movie rather than an interpretation of a book.  I 
thought that POA also flowed quite well; I don't think the past two 
films (POA & GOF) seemed as rushed as the first two.

Beth

Sherry Gomes wrote:

>However, i will be interested
>to hear opinions from everyone who gets to it sooner.  Especially from those
>who didn't particularly like the POA movie because of changes to plot or
>things left out.  POA was so disappointing to me, and so far, all i've read
>sounds like those who liked that one, like this one.  i can't wait to read
>what you all think!
>  
>




More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive