ending question
Sherry Gomes
sherriola at earthlink.net
Sun Nov 20 15:46:52 UTC 2005
read a post somewhere (or a review? I can't remember) that said the film
ended with an unsettled, open-ended feeling, and that's true -- and very,
very creepy. And that kind of ending suits the truly creepy feeling evoked
when
Harry tells Hermione a very simple and heartfelt "Yes" when she says
"Everything's going to change now, isn't it?" His eyes said it all,
despite the
slight, comforting big-brother-ish smile on his face. His eyes were
haunted,
dead, pain-filled, seeing things other people haven't and shouldn't have to
see. It was a wonderfully done bit. And then they tried to get back to
normality, which is how people really act during trying times. At
funerals, people
laugh despite their grief as they share stories about the deceased or catch
up on news with people they haven't seen since the last funeral. It seems
disrespectful, but in all reality, it's life "moving on" because in the
face of
tragedy, the survivors must find a way to move on or collapse in despair,
y'know? Been there, done that, and I think it was a truly brilliant way to
end
it.
Lynda AKA "Abraxan"
Sherry asks:
Ok, I'm one of the two remaining HP fans who haven't seen the movie yet!
Still trying to find someone to go with, in case there are visual things I
need to have explained. Aren't there any adult HP fans in the Seattle area?
Sniffle.
Anyway, how does this somewhat lighter seeming ending--just going on the
descriptions here so far--set up the scene for Harry's mindset and mood at
the beginning of OOTP? He's in pretty bad shape at the beginning of that
one. I'm just curious if people think this ending really gives us that kind
of preparation.
Oh, a comment about Dan's acting. Unlike many apparently, I always thought
Dan was a pretty good Harry. Well, except for that dreadful crying scene in
POA. But since I can't see him, i thought his verbal delivery was really
good, kind of hesitant and unsure of himself, as Harry was in the beginning
of the series. I think Dan's acting has improved and strengthened, as Harry
as gained confidence and become a stronger person through the series. Of
course, Harry's a strong person, but his confidence has grown throughout the
first four books, as he matured and developed. i just always thought Dan's
acting really gave me that impression of the kid stepping into this new
world where everyone knows his name and admires him, from the world of the
Dursleys where he has been abused and unloved. I thought Dan gave me that
confusion and growing confidence quite well.
Sherry
Probably the last remaining HP fan who hasn't been to the movie!
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive