The ending of GoF (was: Random ramblings on GoF)/ Reed's review

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Mon Nov 21 22:55:56 UTC 2005


Charme:
> And for the love of God, you simply must read movie critic Rex 
Reed's column 
> in the New York Observer, as it is apparent that HE has issues 
requiring 
> therapy as he notices (and prints) that Dan has hairy legs, an 
Adam's apple, 
> and a "buldge in his pants"  and Emma Watson has "cleavage." (no, 
these are 
> not my words - they are his.)
> http://www.newyorkobserver.com/culture_rexreed-2.asp
> 
> Much Potter Thanksgiving Love -
> Charme
>

Alla:

Charme, you are back. :-) Please don't disappear on us any more. :-)

As to this review, you know I am a great believer in the idea that 
we could say any things positive or negative about books or movies, 
BUT such criticism only carries any weight for me if the person 
actually saw the movie or read the books and I have a lot of doubt 
that this guy actually saw the movie.

It is what Heidi said on OTC - bodies in every scene?  Wierd....

And of course you are right, he does seem to have  the issues.

Alla,

who is very happy to hear from Charme.







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive