Worried about OoP
ereshkigal_doom
nonnymouse_X at hotmail.com
Tue Nov 29 18:22:56 UTC 2005
--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Krissy" <surreal_44 at y...> wrote:
> He writes to Harry what...four or five times in GoF, and speaks to
him
> once in the fire, right? That would barely be enough to have Harry be
> completely bonded to Sirius. I think alot of the bonding happens in
> OoP when they stay together.
>
I think you are right.
My personal feeling is that the movie makers are anxious to have each
movie stand on its own, without moviegoers needing to have seen or
remembered previous movies. Even if they had done plenty establishing
Sirius's relationship with Harry in GOF, they would have still needed
to re-establish it in in OOP. So this would have been time wasted in a
movie that is already a little long.
The movies are primarily aimed at the general public rather than keen
HP fans. Considering that, I think they are remarkably faithful to the
source material.
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive