[HPFGU-Movie] book vs. movie

Valerie Flowe valerie.flowe at verizon.net
Thu Feb 2 12:32:12 UTC 2006


>  kchuplis:
> <snip> Now PoA they had to start doing a lot more squeezing, trimming 
> and therefore
>  shifting...... Instead, it's a bit puzzling for folks who haven't
>  read the books when GoF starts out with LV calling Peter "Wormtail" 
> since he
>  was always referred to (or overwhelmingly, I certainly don't remember 
> him
>  being called Wormtail much if at all) in PoA.

Ya know, I think the only people who WOULD'VE called him Wormtail, 
which was his nickname, would be Sirius, James and Remus. And how about 
when Wormtail says "...Lord Voldemort". He, of all people, would NEVER 
dare speak his name...he always called him "My Lord", in the books. 
But, of course, this was for clarification in the movie. Who's in the 
chair? Who's that guy hovering? And who's the darn guy with the black 
hair, who WASN'T there in the book? Sigh...I know, I know. It's all 
about consolidation.
Val


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive