[HPFGU-Movie] What kind of list do you want? was Odds and ends

[Karen]

Thank you, Nick for clearing that up. No, much of your post was not 
clear, but you have made it clearer now. I still believe there was a 
lot of furor over something meant as frivolous and light, which you 
also apparently took offense to. Hence, my posts.

As to rehashing topics, I really do not see how you can avoid it. As 
you point out, it takes a substantial amount of time to go back and 
read years worth of posts. I somehow feel we are being hand slapped 
again. I, indeed, *would* like more in depth discussion but light 
heartedness is never out of line IMO. In fact, there were some bits of 
camera work I was thinking about talking about in PoA and some other 
technical details, but it seems, if I tread on toes, as others seem to 
have done, by bringing up something 2 years ago when PoA was released, 
I might just be boring you and stepping out of what you want from the 
list. I believe what is bothering me most is that you wish a closed 
list with people who have been here all along so as not to bother you 
with repetition. I'm very sorry that I don't have a time turner to 
oblige. I know, I'm sounding tetchy again, but I felt (not speaking for 
the entire list just that *I* felt) that I was being preached to again 
about posting. I really would like to know what the crime is. If I am, 
indeed, expected to reread years of posts, then I'm afraid this isn't 
the list for  me. I am rather late to the Potter world. Just never had 
been exposed until, really, this last year when a friend really pushed 
me to read the books and see the movies. I guess I am one of those 
offensive bandwagon jumpers. Better late than never, I guess, but I 
didn't know it was a rule.

I will attempt to remain in lurk mode in honor of long time listers, 
but I can't promise anything if I see a post I want to respond to. As 
you can tell, I am a bit of a loud mouth.

cheers again
Karen