will dobby return for order of the pheonix
susanbones2003
rkdas at charter.net
Tue Feb 7 00:43:36 UTC 2006
--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "fuzz876i" <fuzz876i at ...> wrote:
>
> In The Goblet of Fire i missed seeing Dobby. In the book he seemed
to
> bring about the second task with the gillyweed. In the Order of the
> Phoenix he provides the information of the room of requirement and
> tells Harry this is a good place for Dumbledore's Army to meet. If
he
> does not return in The Order of the Pheonix then will he return in
The
> Half-blood prince or so you think they will omith the parts about
> Kreacher and Dobby both in either movie any thoughts?
> Fuzz876i
Hiya Fuzz,
There was some thought on this list that since Dobby didn't make it
into GOF, that most likely the screenwriters/director will omit house
elves in OOP as well. I can't give you the specific post numbers but
searching our list is not so onerous as the main list and you'll find
it within the last 2 months or so, no doubt. According to our dearly
departed former member Richard, Kreacher's role can easily be gotten
around and they don't seem to need to keep in anything they can
possibly omit.(He also wrote a great post detailing what he thought
WOULD be in OOP, also worth a search) So don't get your hopes up for
either elf next go round. After all, we already know we have one
character to satisfy our CG needs, Grawp! Just take it as a clue that
Dobby is not integral to the series as a whole if you don't see him.
Jen D.incapable of coming up with anything snappy to say at this
juncture...
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive