[HPFGU-Movie] Re: SB/RL ship in OOtP- was: Oldman and Thewlis

[Karen]

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "chintz22" <chintz22 at yahoo.com>


Thanks for the responses.  To weigh in on this topic in more detail, I
think the whole question of SB/RL is open ended.  For me there's
certainly enough evidence in POA the film and OOP the book to make it a
possibility, but I'm not wedded to the idea (pardon the pun).  I
definitely felt an undercurrent of it in POA the film, but I don't know
who was responsible-the director, the scriptwriter, the actors?  Since
OOP has a different director and scriptwriter it will be interesting to
see if there is any subtext in the new film (somehow, I could see
Oldman trying to slip something in...).

kchuplis:
I'm curious. What in the film led you to feel this? I've watched it maybe 5
times now, and it would never have led me to this conclusion. Is it
something in the actors performance? Any dialogue in particular? I just have
never understood where these ideas come from.