The age of Harry's parents...

laurenmcoakley laurenmcoakley at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 11 17:26:38 UTC 2006


--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Elvine Elvine" <elvine78 at h...> 
wrote:
>
> Lauren:
> >I think I brought this up earlier, but I never got back to it, 
> >so now I'm mentioning it again... did anyone else think Harry's 
> >parents looked older than maybe they should've during the whole 
> >Priori Incantatem sequence?  My expectation was that they would 
> >be the same age as they were when they were killed by Voldemort's 
> >wand, however, especially Harry's dad, seemed quite aged in 
> >comparison to his twenty-something self when he died.
> >
> >After seeing this movie for the 4th time, I can say that this 
> >point still perplexes me.  Am I missing something?

Elvine:
> As Harry's parents are supposed to be the same age as Snape, who, 
> in the films, can hardly pass for being in his late 30's, they've 
> had to age up Harry's parents as well.
SNIP

Lauren again:
It is my opinion that ghosts would appear the age they were when 
they died.  Isn't that true for Moaning Myrtle & Nearly Headless 
Nick et al?  I just thought it seemed out of place that James Potter 
seemed like he was gray and balding.  I would expect him to be young 
like the photo Harry has of him next to his bed in PoA.  IMOH

Does anyone agree with me on this one?







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive