[HPFGU-Movie] Re: What trio? /was" HP Flubs"

[Susanne]

Hi,

Wednesday, July 5, 2006, 2:42:15 PM, rkdas at charter.net wrote:

> No, it 
> isn't a "BIG" moment but it struck me as much more believeable than
> the confrontation scene between Hermione and Ron after the Yule Ball.

I think all this depends on personal interpretation and
opinion and feelings.
Other people have mentioned the Yule Ball scene as
excellent and one of their favorites.

Some people see great screen chemistry between movie Harry and
Hermione,
and see it extend beyond the friendship they are portraying
while others just see them act like good friends and see the
tension between Ron and Hermione.

Sometimes I think we, the hardcore fans who join lists and
forums and read a lot about the actors and behind the scenes
stuff get influenced into reading more into little things
that casual viewers don't at all.

And I do believe Mr. Cuaron is guilty of setting the H/Hr
mood in PoA, because of what I've read in interviews with him.
He just went out of his way with a nod to his own movie, adding
ambiguity to a scene that was much clearer in the books, and he
seemed to think Dan and Emma were just so sexy when running
around in the forest disheveled and dirty. ;)
>From the same interviews I got the feeling he did not
understand or have a connection with Rupert, who is much
quieter than Dan and Emma.
Sometimes people who aren't outgoing and demostrative are
misunderstood as being off in their own world and
not "interesting".

All this is of course just my personal opinion from what
I've read or observed.

I'm glad Rupert's non HP movie is well liked by most critics
and the audiences at festivals.
Am looking forward to hearing more about Dan's other film,
too.

-- 
Best regards,
 Susanne                           mailto:siskiou at vcem.com