Movies vs Books (was What trio?)

juli17 at aol.com juli17 at aol.com
Fri Jul 21 04:30:33 UTC 2006


 
Candace wrote:

Personally, for the moviegoers (only), I think it could end with HBP.   Lots 
of movies end with a hint of some new great adventure coming but you know  
there won't be a movie about it.  So Harry saying i'm not going back to  school 
and looking for a bits of Volderdork's soul can seem like one of those  endings 
in my opinion.  Now for someone like myself, i would need  whatever movie 
book 7 is made into, because I was obssessed before I read the  books.





Julie:
I actually think the 7th *book* will end with a hint of some new great  
adventure 
coming for Harry and those who survive. They'll all continue to exist and  
have
adventures in their world parellel to ours (which is kind of a neat idea).  
If the
movies did end with HBP, it wouldn't really leave us with a hint of a new  
great 
adventure, but an abrupt cliffhanger to a story spanning six previous  movies,
that being the story of Harry Potter the Boy Who Lived and his destiny  to
confront the bane of his (and many other wizards') existence, Lord  Voldemort.
It's really been one long story, after all. 
 
But I feel certain if a 6th movie is made then a 7th one will  
follow--really, why
would Warner Bros consider for a moment giving up THAT revenue?!!.  I'd
also point out that we don't really know what will happen in Book 7,  other
than a final confrontation between Harry and Voldemort. Harry *says*  he's
not going back to school, but he's not writing Book 7 ;-) And those  horcruxes
do need to be destroyed, but we can't even be sure Harry will do it, let  
alone
how long it will take. In fact, what we *think* will happen is almost sure  
not
to happen, if previous track records for predictions are any  indication!
 
Julie
 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive