GoF comments on movie

jeanico2000 jheiler at sympatico.ca
Thu Mar 9 12:55:58 UTC 2006


--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, Ellen Joy Dioso <ejdioso at ...> 
wrote:
>
> Karen <kchuplis at ...> wrote:     
> So, I had never read any of the reviews before, but recently went 
to 
> rottentomatos to check out what folks had said regarding GoF.  I 
was 
> surprised to see some griping about the presentation of LV. You 
know, 
> I just don't know what they wanted. To be honest, rewatching GoF 
the 
> last couple of days, I have the same visceral reaction as I did in 
> the theater. I just about want to vomit. I don't know what more 
one 
> could ask for than Ralph Fiennes portrayal. When he touches 
Cederic 
> with his foot....UGH!!! That is a NASTY person. And he is just 
insane. 
> Not in Crouch way either. In a silky frightening way.  And to me 
Dan 
> was certainly convincing. But of course the scene that still gets 
me 
> the most is the return with the body. I find it riveting and sad 
and 
> really pretty traumatic. <snip>
>  
>   
> ejdioso:  
> The story's nice....honestly, I'm not touched when Cedric died....
> it's just part of the story...I know I will cry when it comes to 
the 
> point that Daniel will die....
>

erm... that's a bit creepy! don't mix up Daniel with Harry, please!
and I'm still hoping that JK will let our hero live at the end of 
book 7 :o)
   









More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive