[HPFGU-Movie] New to the list and some questions

[Michelle A. Tague]

W elcome!  I love all the movies... I think SS was the closest...  
 
The part that really irritated me the most in the movies was the PoA... that
Lupin didn't tell Harry who the creators of the marauders map were...
and how close he really was to his mother and father.  I thought that was a
hugely important part of the plot line.
 
OOTP was my absolutely least favorite book, so there isn't much of it that
I'm looking forward to...although I'm going to gooble up every moment I'm
sure.
 
Ask away, this is a relaxed list.
 
michelle, a 36 year old Philadelphian who's a HUGE HP fan. ;-)


Hi everyone. I'm pretty new to the HPFGU's lists and this is my first 
post on the movie list. I hope it's not improper to post a series of 
questions but I was just wondering:

Which movie do you feel is closest to its corresponding book?

Which movie plot omission do you feel most betrays the stories?

What scene in OOTP are you most looking forward to?

I have more but I don't want to overstep my bounds, especially as a 
newbie! :o)

Thanks for indulging my curiosity and love of all things Harry!

Stacey



 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]