A couple of OotP puzzles for me

[Lizzie Mae Lilly]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" <justcarol67 at ...> 
wrote:
>
> 
> Also, didn't having Cho confess to Umbridge mean that Umbridge used
> Veritaserum on her, which would mean that Snape must have supplied her
> with real rather than fake Veritaserum? If so, there goes his subtle
> undermining of Umbridge. And he didn't even get his Babbling Beverage
> line or his order to crabbe to release his chokehold on Neville. Sigh!
> 
> Carol, who thought that Snape seemed more sinister and scary in this
> film than the earlier ones, possibly to prepare for the "murder" in 
HBP
>

If Severus gave Umbridge real veritaserum for the students why was Cho 
the only one who spilled the beans?  That's what didn't make sense to 
me.  Umbridge offered tea to the first student so I assume it was 
doped.  Perhaps Cho was the last one interrogated and she might have 
panicked from anxiety and betrayed the DA. See what happens when you 
vear away from the story! 

Taken as a whole I enjoyed the movie very much (two viewings -- so 
far), but there are inconsistencies aplenty!! 

Lizzie