DH Movie Speculation

[apetersonhanson]

Steph <stephab67 at yahoo.com> wrote:
> <snip>
> -Characters in/out: In: Kreacher, obviously. Out:
> Dobby. It's possible that Dobby might be back for
> HBP, but I doubt it, which means that there's no
> way they'll bring him back for DH as it will have
> been too long since he's been seen on screen. I
> suspect Kreacher will save Harry et al in Malfoy
> Mansion and be the one to die. It would in a way
> make sense for Kreacher's character arc as well.
> Goes from hating Harry to dying for him. Griphook
> - in.
>
> I'm up in the air about Percy. He was in OotP but
> didn't have any lines and wasn't identified by name.
> I hope he's in but I'm not going to be surprised if
> he's out. <snip> Xeno Lovegood - likely out, see
> below. I'm up in the air about Aunt Muriel and Elphias
> Doge.
>
> They'll probably skip the Xeno Lovegood house scene
> all together and just have Hermione figure out the
> story of the wand, the stone, and the cloak. <snip>

Alicia:
They can't cut Xeno Lovegood, the whole Xeno lying about
Luna being fishing for plimpies and then trying to give
Harry to DEs sets up for Malfoy manor and finding Luna
in the dungeon.

Also I hate Dobby too but they have to have Dobby resue
/die for Harry because that introduces Aberforth later
and how he sent Dobby and how it was his eye in the mirror,
not DD's eye. AND, when Griphook sees how Harry cares for
Dobby and buries him by hand it swings Griphook into
helping w/ the break in to the Lestrange vault which w/out
Griphook couldn't happen.  Plus then we have the whole
thing of Griphook wanting the sword of Gryffindor and the
trio needing it to destroy horcruxes.

Percy has to be in, if only for the battle, because he is
the Weasley missing from the wedding and the whole life of
the family. Then when he changes his mind and shows up to
fight it's a reunion followed by Charlie coming from
Romania too. Then all the Weasleys fight as one.

Hermione can't tell the story of the Deathly Hallows
because she would never believe it to be real, w/out Xeno
none of them would think it real, remember Xeno is the one
who makes the trio realize that Harry's cloak is like no
other cloak, it doesn't fade over the yrs, etc.

We have to have Ron's aunt and Doge because that is what
makes Harry want to talk to Bagshot after reading part
of Skeeter's book.  I love the books and am sad about all
that was changed/left out of OotP the movie.

I will have a heart attack if DH isn't perfectly in sync w/
the book. I do agree with you that they will change things,
but why? I wouldn't care if the movie was 6 hours long,
would any real Potter fan?  I loved HBP, that and DH were
my favorite books so I really can't wait for the movies.

I am having a hard time w/ the series ending and almost
wish JKR would start a spin-off one involving the trios'
kids and Draco's kid, Neville's kids, etc.  Harry could be
the new DD, and maybe Lucius finds the resurrection stone
and brings back Bellatrix or something.  Who knows, I am
sad to see it over and think it could have been wrapped up
better if she wrote DH but didn't end it, and then wrote
an 8th book to tie up all loose ends.

alicia