Snape's Worst Memory

verosomm verosomm at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 11 17:28:29 UTC 2007


MOVIE 5 SPOILERS!

S
*
P
*
O
*
I
*
L
*
E
*
R


S
*
P
*
A
*
C
*
E

Ok, I think that's enough space... anyone else wondering why Snape's 
Worst Memory was such a short clip?  I understand that because they 
didn't do it like a Pensieve, and Snape was fighting back on Harry's 
countercurse, it was going to be quick, but IF if turns out Snape 
was in love with Lily as many on the book list speculate, this is 
not going to be enough to mollify the movie-only HP fan, no, esp. 
since Lily was not in the scene!  But I understand they don't like 
to leave too many loose ends in the movies like JKR does in the 
books.  

I guess I was just surprised at 1) how short it was 2) no Lily 
to "save" Snape and no Snape attacking her with the "mudblood" 
insult and ESPECIALLY 3) no Sirius and Remus telling Harry how James 
really WAS an ok person, just not perfect, and grew out of the "15-
year-old prat" stage, which, in my opinion, would have fit in 
perfectly with Harry and Sirius's talk in which Harry is worried 
about his anger.

And, anyone remember what Harry's countercurse/ shield charm to 
Snape's legilemens (sorry if that's spelled incorrectly) was?

Veronica, who thought it was actually the most accurate film thus 
far, and doesn't mind MOST of the changes 






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive