Question about scene in OotP

[cubfanbudwoman]

Troy answers:
> In a related scene, there is a part of the movie that I feel was 
> completele rubbish was (as it was completely not true to the 
> book). . .
 
 SPOILER
 *******
 
 SPOILER
 *******
 
 SPOILER
 *******
 
 SPOILER
 *******
> 
> 
> . . . because the same kind of torture was used on others besides 
> Harry.  At one point, it shows a whole classroom of students (I 
think 
> all were members of the DA) writing with the "Blood Quills."  
Also, 
> in another scene, the twins are comforting a student that is 
having a 
> hard time dealing with the pain in his hand, much to Prof. Umb.'s 
> twisted satisfaction.

SSSusan:
Yes, that did seem a little baffling, why the entire DA was made to 
use the cut-and-bleed quills.  

And what *really* creeped me out about that scene was Umbridge's... 
well... more than twisted satisfaction.  I mean, it *was* that, but 
the look on her face and the sick little sigh she gave... she 
appeared so sadistic in that moment that she almost seemed to be 
getting off on it in a sexual way.

Bleh.

Siriusly Snapey Susan,
who enjoyed most of the movie very much but who, like Oryomai, can't 
wait to see it again so she can ponder things more fully