OOTP Movie

[Arwen17]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, OctobersChild48 at ... wrote:
>
>
> Did anyone else notice that in the book an  unidentified green jet
> > of light killed Sirius but in the movie it was  definitely an
AK?? I
> > didn't like that Sirius was dead before he went  through the veil.
>
>
>
> zanooda:
>
> In the book it was not even green :-). The first jet of light
Bella
> sent at Sirius was red (Stupefy?), and the one that sent him
through
> the  veil was just "the second jet of light", no color specified.
>
> Sirius was  definitely alive in the book when he went through the
> veil, fear and  surprise in his eyes etc. I didn't watch the movie
> yet, so I can't tell if  you are right, but if you are, I don't
like
> it either. I always thought  maybe it was important that Sirius
wasn't
> dead when he went through the  veil.
>
>
>
> Sandy:
>
> I saw the movie tonight and Bella killed Sirius with an AK,
accompanied by
> the green jet of light, and Sirius was dead when he went through
the veil. It
> was one of many inconsistencies, but the movie was good despite
them. I really
>  like this movie.
>
> Sandy


If it was significally important JKR wouldn't have allowed them to
change it. She does look at everything they do and tell them if
something might conflict with something in the future. They weren't
going to originally include Kreacher, but she told them they really
might wanna or they'll paint themselves into a corner later.


Arwen