[HPFGU-Movie] Re: OOTP Movie

[SnapesSlytherin at aol.com]

>Karen wrote: 
"I will never understand small nits like this. The fact is, Sirius
died. Does it really matter if he was AK'd or fell through the veil?"

>Troy replies:
Well, Karen, I guess you are entitled to your opinion, but I (along 
with several others) have a different opinion. Call it wishful 
thinking, but a lot of us do not treat Sirius being dead, as fact.

I don't think that it is nit-picky, since it is such an important part 
of our theories that Sirius is somehow still alive on the other side of 
the veil.

Although, perhaps JKR had the movie writers tie up a loose end that she 
decided she didn't want to pursue in the last book.

Besides, I personally get great enjoyment from discussing the small 
details.



.


Oryomai:
It's definitely important.? The fact that it was an unidentified jet of light (and I'm ironing my hands over the color mix-up!) and NOT an AK is actually an important point.? If JKR had wanted it to be easily identifiable as an AK, she would've said "Bellatrix deviously AK'd Sirius."? She would have told us that's what it was.? We have no idea what dying through the veil does -- we don't even know what's behind it.? That *definitely* makes a difference in death.
It's even more important if Sirius turns out not to be truly dead.? If he isn't dead, then the movie!AK messes it up.

Oryomai
Who thinks Sirius is dead, but that it wasn't an AK that killed him


________________________________________________________________________
AOL now offers free email to everyone.  Find out more about what's free from AOL at AOL.com.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]