[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Question about Sirius

[Mike Daron]

 on Sirius went in a invisibility cloak as he turn in to a wolf.that they didn't see.
   well in the book when I read it. near thew end harry was talking to ginny, when
  harry notice a hint of a black paw.then I knew that Sirius is still in hinding...
   re-read book 6, mike .
  
Emily <imamommy at sbcglobal.net> wrote: 
          --- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, zpavri at ... wrote:
>
> I read the Order of the Phoenix a while back, so I really don't 
remember it 
> too well, I was curious about one thing. How many of you feel 
that Sirius is 
> indeed dead? Could he still be alive? In the movie Goblet of 
Fire when 
> Wormtail uses the AK curse on Cedric...Cedric is killed 
instantly. However in 
> the Order of the Phoenix movie, when Bellatrix uses the AK curse 
on Sirius..he 
> floats away ...I don't understand that part? 

imamommy:
I think this was a filmmaker screw-up. In the book, Sirius is not 
hit with an AK; the spell is a stunning spell, IIRC. Thus, he is 
stunned and sort of falls into the archway.
My guess was that they used AK in the film to make sure the audience 
knew he was really dead. So, we'll have to see if they shot 
themselves in the foot or not.



         

       
---------------------------------
Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]