Question about Sirius/ Other comments

colebiancardi muellem at bc.edu
Tue Jul 17 02:14:48 UTC 2007


> "Richelle Votaw" <rvotaw at ...> wrote:
> 
> 1) Snape--The people I've talked to who saw it without reading the book
> didn't realize it was Snape who alerted the Order to Harry and co.
heading
> off to London.  Come on, Snape needs all the credit he can get for
being a
> good guy!  I realize we were supposed to catch the Padfoot comment
and put
> it all together, but most people who didn't know haven't.

colebiancardi:

we lost that whole scene with DD explaining it all to Harry.  Perhaps
in movie 6, we will get a recap?  

Or maybe not.  Barty Crouch Jr *never* died in movie 4.  And they
still haven't explained that.  Nor Igor's death....

 
> 4) Kreacher--I noticed this time around that Sirius says "Away with
you" to
> him, even though we don't find out that Kreacher went to the
Malfoys, maybe
> that's still important?

colebiancardi:

I *hope* so - maybe that will be *revealed* in movie 6, as part of the
recap that I mentioned up above.  

It is a good thing they called Sirius *Padfoot* at the beginning of
this movie, or else no one (who hadn't read the books) would have
gotten Harry's reference to Snape in Umbridge's office.  I wonder how
many people paid attention to that? For those that didn't read the
books, that is.....




 






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive