[HPFGU-Movie] Re: I KNOW this is the Movie list but...

[AnitaKH]

Might be construed to have spoilers, although I'm trying very hard...

Jade B <jade76_2000 at yahoo.com> wrote, in response to Valerie's welcome, if slightly off-topic message stating her response to DH:                                  Yeah it was hard to be on the internet and skip over spoiler areas (which seemed to be everywhere at the time). I was shocked, I cried, I laughed. WOW is right.
    
   Jade


akh pipes up:
First - I loved the book to the point that I don't mind at all that she included some of my least-favorite concepts discussed on TOL.  Now, on to my point...

In a closer-to-movies, vein, now that we have all the books, I've been ruminating over the parts of POA that gave JKR 'chills' when she watched the movie for the first time.  I had limited myself to visuals, since in theory she would have known in advance about the dialogue, but now I'm rethinking that position.  I had already decided that one of them was Buckbeak attacking Lupin, in anticipation of his attack in book 6, but do y'all think the bridge scene with Lupin and Harry is another, even though it's really the dialogue that foreshadows 7?  Maybe Cuaron asked for that scene as a pickup.  



At any rate, I'd love to hear other ideas.

akh, who has NO idea how this is going to format!  (apologies if it's completely whacked)


 






[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]